House historian and professional genealogist Marian Pierre-Louis
writes the kind of blog that generates discussion. Her post yesterday in Marian’s Roots and Rambles was no
exception. She asked,
What is networking? And is it
worth the effort?
Her main focus was in questioning whether networking
actually helps genealogists and family historians—either professionals or
hobbyists—attain their research goals.
I say it does.
Whether you consider the term “networking” from a
traditional perspective or Web 2.0 framework, I’d say that networking does have
its place in enhancing the research process. It’s just that the improvement may
not be readily quantifiable—it may be downright invisible to those who come by it naturally. It’s hard to measure how something keeps you from
lesser results than you might have otherwise had, especially when day-to-day genealogy pursuits are already earmarked with so many results of community efforts. And we can't acknowledge with due gratefulness what we don't perceive as the blessings sent our way through others' contributions.
My Bias: Networking
in my Roots
Marian mentioned that, to her, networking was something
intuitive—something inherited or absorbed by osmosis from her mom.
I owe my dad that same disclaimer: I got it from him. He was
the type of guy who knew everyone—and everyone knew him. He was a musician—but
also a teacher and a businessman. He mastered the art of just hanging out. He
took the time to get to know people. And people thrive when they are around
someone who cares. Our family used to joke that we couldn’t go anywhere without
bumping into someone who knew our dad—no matter how far from home we traveled.
One day, I sat down and wrote up everything I had learned
about networking by watching my dad—and by realizing all the benefits that our family
reaped from his tendency to network. I actually ended up using that list as the
basis of a seminar I taught at a conference.
Of course, that was before the era of widespread personal
computer usage, but the rudimentary basics remain the same. It’s just the
equipment that’s gotten souped up. With no cell phone, no laptop computer, no
wifi, no social media, I guess you could say my dad could network with one half
of our connectivity tied behind his
back.
My Track Record:
Being the Recipient of Networking Benefits
Last month, one of my readers (and a blogger in his own right) found a way to obtain an old
book that happened to mention some details of my husband’s Chicago family from the late 1800s. After
discussing the discovery with me via email, he decided to buy a used copy of
the book and mail it to me.
Holding that book in my hands, I can’t tell you how awe-struck I am when I leaf through those
pages and see our ancestors’ names woven into the narrative of that story. But
I can tell you that, if it weren’t for networking, I would never have received
the gift of that book, for I’ve never met this reader. I know him only courtesy
of online networking. Another blogger whom I’ve also never met, Far Side of Fifty, connected me with this researcher. Through Far Side’s blog, Forgotten Old Photos, I had been trying
to learn how to delve into the historic details of old photographs—observing her
posts religiously and commenting and asking questions. Somehow, that prompted
her to connect me with this other researcher. It was a moment of networking
that didn’t cost anyone much of anything—but I’m glad it happened.
I could go on and on about networking serendipity—the very
fact that I now know which surname to research for my father’s elusive paternal
line is owing to an unexpected tip from someone in the old FamilyTreeMaker users’
network—but I’m sure you have as many stories as I have.
I think we can hypothesize about whether networking is worth
all the fuss for endless hours. But until we not only give it a try, but put
some effort into making it a part of our life, we can’t do justice to the concept
by our speculation. We really need to take networking out for a test drive,
read the operating manual and get ourselves educated about this machine we’re
about to co-opt. We need to get a rubber-meets-the-road feel for this
networking operation and how it connects like-minded people and enables them to
collectively achieve their goals.
The Rub: Meeting the Digital Road
When you take that ageless ability to branch out and meet
others—to take the initiative to strike up a conversation and see where it
leads—and fuse it with the technology we have at our fingertips today,
networking has the potential to exponentially grow those traditional results.
While the old one-on-one path of “getting to know you” established trust
through doing face-to-face time, the newer path absolutely demands integrity in networking—yet opens the doors for the shy as
well as the charismatic to participate. While the old route seemed to favor
that “good ol’ boy” network, the newer way levels the playing field to
facilitate meetings that might not, with the staunch gatekeepers of bygone
eras, have ever occurred. The Internet
Highway hasn’t really changed the rules; it has
just changed the magnitude of possibilities.
And this way isn’t just “All About Me.” I see it as
technology’s way of facilitating a new form of the Golden Rule. We can’t just
think of networking in terms of what it can do for me. We need to be willing to give before we can expect to get. To
realize that thinking about you is
good business for me.
Looking for Help in
So Many More Places
Genealogists and family history researchers have always
pursued an impossible dream: there is always one more ancestor to find, yet one
more reference volume to consult, just one more database to check. Even if we could achieve that “one more” dream, it
would be impossible to attain it alone.
We have to face the fact that research is really a team effort.
With the explosion of genealogical resources both online and
off, there is no possible way one person could read it all, record it all, and
share it all.
Without a network.
And really—isn’t it true that everything we have already
found came with the help of others?
Think of those neophyte years, just learning the ropes of
researching, benefiting from the experience—and sometimes the actual data—of other,
more seasoned, researchers.
Think of all those queries written to far-flung genealogy
societies, hoping that someone in the Perry County Genealogical Society’s
newsletter—or the Harper County GenWeb, or the Pottawatomie County Rootsweb
mailing list—could answer my brick-wall question.
Think of that quick and easy post on GenForum or Ancestry’s
message boards, asking for a local member to do one of those Random Acts of
Genealogical Kindness and perform a lookup.
Think of tweeting a latest genealogy find—“Got my DNA
results back today!!!”—and adding the hashtag so everyone in the Twitterverse
well-versed in #genealogy could share your moment.
And then think how easy technology has made it for us to not
only stand there with our electronic hand out, waiting for someone to “gimme”—but
also be able to turn around and retweet, Facebook “Like” or Google+ someone
else’s insight or notable accomplishment. Every hyperlink you find in any blog post is a writer's way of sharing—read: networking—a new resource with you. The Internet was made for networking. It is a vehicle for collaboration.
Coming to a Place of
Gratefulness
When I think of all those possibilities—of giving as well as
e-getting—I realize what a powerful position we now find ourselves in as
genealogy researchers. We can retweet, along with @marianpl, Ancestry.com’s jubilation
that the 1940 census is now fully indexed—a feat, itself, that could never have
happened with such speed without the connectivity of the internet and the
social proofing of all those validating online friends. We networked to gather
such a group of volunteers and get them on a roll. It was a matter of friends
passing the word along to friends to the “sixth degree of separation” and
beyond.
To merely wonder whether networking is worth someone’s time
and effort is rather short-sighted in view of the powerful benefits cascading
down on us as we reach out and research. Without the equipment and technology
afforded us through the interconnectivity of Web 2.0 systems—the social media
we’ve come to take for granted (as if we couldn’t remember a day before cell
phones)—and without those rudimentary skills of reaching out and getting to
know the person next to us (whether physically or by special interest
categories), we could never have accomplished all that we have achieved in our
genealogy research. Whether you consider this collectively (as in the 1940
indexing project) or individually (as in each researcher’s willingness to post
her family tree in an online format), we have an awesome opportunity to accelerate
our genealogical accomplishments by using the resources at hand that allow us
to connect with others keen on pursuing those unique-yet-shared interests.
I’d say that kind of networking goes far beyond the realm of “Is it worth the
effort?” To me, it’s a matter of “How could I not take advantage of the benefits.”
Photograph, above right: Agnes Dockery O'Brien, born about 1873 in Wisconsin; from the private collection of the descendants of Edna Tully McCaughey.
For the original blog post, see: Marian's Roots and Rambles: What is networking? And is it worth the effort?
Photograph, above right: Agnes Dockery O'Brien, born about 1873 in Wisconsin; from the private collection of the descendants of Edna Tully McCaughey.
For the original blog post, see: Marian's Roots and Rambles: What is networking? And is it worth the effort?
