Monday, October 20, 2014

Working Around the System


I close my eyes and can still see the calligraphic lines of Father James Flanagan's hand rhythmically unfolding across the pages of the Ballyagran parish register. Those dark images of the 1830s are still imprinted on my mind. I will likely carry their memory with me on my journey back across the Atlantic—but clutch my files in safekeeping in my carry-on bags, just in case.

This research trip to Ireland, home of my Irish-American father-in-law's eight great-grandparents, has given me three weeks of material to mull over. There have been moments to ponder. Moments in which time stood still as I sensed intangible connections. And long stretches of time, seeking the unfindable.

Researching outside one's own country brings a person face-to-face with one's own assumptions. And those assumptions often crumble in the face of reality. What we take for granted through our experience, researching at home, will not always be the same system we encounter abroad. While Americans traipse merrily along the unwinding trail from the 1940 census backwards through the decades at home, their immigrant ancestors left behind governments which might not even be in existence now.

"Frame of reference" has become a buzzword for this month's research experience. In the States, we expect our government to collect certain types of information, and learn how to extract from those documents what is useful for our genealogical pursuits. We expect to cross-apply that assumption to the governments of our ancestors. This does not always hold true. Other governments—indeed, other organizations in general—collect vastly different types of information based on what suits their purposes. I spent the greater part of this last week, essentially conducting the equivalent of what, in America, might be looking at rent rolls of apartment managers—all in the interest of finding some clue as to the whereabouts of my husband's ancestors.

If documents are basically collections of what "We the People" deem important for our government to record and store, they become a window through which others may glean hints of what we count as important. As much as Americans see themselves as being from a "young" country—after all, empires like those of the British and even more so the Chinese, vastly outclass our history—as American genealogists, we blithely flip through the pages of our decennial census records in one form or another, (with only one hiccup), back through 1790. Yet from where I have traveled this month, I could photograph the ruins of an Irish monastery or castle dating from years labeled with only three digits, yet drive less than an hour to access census records that can't reach beyond 1901.

For those of Irish Catholic heritage, this could mean struggling with the researcher's brick wall as recently as the late 1820s. An Irish immigrant willing to brave the unknown to cross the sea to a New World in the 1600s would have had a better chance of being discovered by a descendant in American documents than would his siblings who remained behind in their homeland.

I learned, in this past week, to adopt a "systems" frame of reference in assessing my progress in research here in Ireland. We as researchers will only be able to access what has been left behind by a country's collective determination of what is of value to them. The systems each country has developed, over the decades—and even centuries—leave behind records which may be of value to us in tracing our roots. The key is to determine which system has collected the names, dates and identities which provide the clues we seek. While every system of collective activity will accumulate paper trails, we can never assume the systems we've come to take for granted in our own country will be the same ones valued—or even practiced—in another country.



 



6 comments:

  1. What ever can be gleaned is better than nothing. Thank goodness your important papers are in your carry on:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I'm certainly glad for every shred of information I was able to find. It was quite a learning experience, though--one custom designed to challenge all assumptions!

      Delete
  2. So very true, Jacqi. Very insightful thoughts into the process that so many of us face as we trace the roots of our ancestors who immigrated in relatively recent generations.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thankfully, we learn from each other, LIsa, and from those in other countries who can guide us through the documents and forms of records used in these other places. No matter how accustomed we are to finding our way around, genealogically, in our own country, we can look forward to a steep learning curve, once we cross the borders into the homes of our ancestors. Still, it's an adventure and a challenge--part of what makes this pursuit of genealogy so alluring. And so frustrating.

      Delete
  3. You express the why so well - I've been most reluctant to take my family search across the Atlantic Ocean. It is most difficult - unless your family was a royal one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, ours was most certainly not a royal family, but it has been interesting to see how much we were able to find on our family's roots right from here in the United States.

      I think the earlier in time one's ancestors arrived in America, the harder it would be to trace them in their homeland, but even then, it depends on the individual family's own circumstances. Catholic peasants in Ireland before 1830? I'm afraid we were out of luck. But others in our research group found ways to trace their lines back through other legal documentation. I suspect such processes would work fairly effectively in Great Britain itself, as well. Many foreign-to-us repositories of information may be accessible online, but it takes familiarizing ourselves with the local resources.

      Now that I've begun my work in Ireland, I am discovering all sorts of online resources I hadn't known of before. Learning is most definitely incremental--especially in areas such as this! I've always been a firm believer in learning by osmosis, and learning by doing--and I'm having ample chances to put those beliefs into action in this new area.

      Delete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...